Blog
The Science of Follow-Up: How Many Attempts It Really Takes to Convert a Lead
How many times should a BDC agent contact a lead before giving up? Ask ten different sales managers, and you might get ten different answers. Three calls and an email? Five touches? Contact them until they buy or die? The lack of a standard, data-driven answer to this fundamental question costs car dealerships thousands of opportunities every year. Most teams either give up too soon, leaving profitable deals on the table, or follow up inconsistently, annoying customers and wasting time.
The truth is that effective follow-up isn’t about guesswork or gut feelings; it’s a science. It involves a strategic blend of persistence, timing, channel variation, and psychology. A well-executed follow-up system can be the single greatest differentiator for your car dealership BDC, allowing you to reactivate 20-40% of leads that your competitors would label as “dead.”
This definitive guide will deconstruct the science of follow-up for the modern automotive BDC. We will provide proven cadence blueprints, multi-channel timing strategies, and the exact word tracks needed to convert more leads into showroom appointments. Forget the myths and outdated rules. This is the data-backed playbook for building a relentless and effective follow-up machine that drives measurable growth in your dealership.
The Great Follow-Up Myth: Why Most Dealerships Get It Wrong
The biggest myth in car sales lead management is that a customer who doesn’t respond after two or three attempts isn’t interested. This misconception is born from a salesperson’s fear of being annoying, but it’s not supported by data. In reality, the majority of sales in any industry happen after the fifth contact. Yet, studies consistently show that many salespeople give up after just one or two attempts.
In the automotive world, this problem is magnified. A vehicle purchase is a major decision, and the customer’s journey is rarely linear. They get busy, distracted, or are simply in the early research phase. Giving up too early means you are forfeiting the opportunity to connect with them at the exact moment they are ready to act.
A modern sales BDC process recognizes this reality. It replaces sporadic, half-hearted attempts with a structured, persistent, and multi-channel cadence. This requires robust automotive BDC training and a commitment to process, moving your team from a reactive automotive call center to a proactive revenue engine.
Data-Backed Cadence Blueprints for Every Lead Type
A one-size-fits-all follow-up plan doesn’t work. The source of the lead and their position in the buying journey dictate the optimal cadence. Below are detailed blueprints your car dealership BDC can implement immediately.
Cadence 1: The Inbound Internet Lead (Website, 3rd Party, Chat)
This lead is actively shopping and has high intent. Speed and initial persistence are critical. The goal is to make meaningful contact within the first 48 hours.
The “First 48” Inbound Cadence (10 Touches)
- Within 5 Minutes (Touch 1 & 2): Automated Text + Personal Video Introduction. The text confirms receipt, and the video puts a human face to the name. This is the cornerstone of a modern digital retail BDC strategy.
- Hour 1 (Touch 3): Phone Call #1. If no answer, leave a value-driven voicemail.
- Voicemail Script: “Hi [Customer Name], this is [Agent Name] from [Dealership Name] following up on the [Year Make Model] inquiry. I sent you a quick personal video just a few minutes ago. My goal is simple: to make sure you have all the information you need. My direct line is [Number].”
- Hour 4 (Touch 4): Email #1. Include the video link again, plus a clear call-to-action (e.g., “When is a good time for a 3-minute call to confirm availability and pricing?”).
- Day 2 (Touch 5): Phone Call #2 (morning).
- Day 2 (Touch 6): Text Message #2. Keep it simple and conversational.
- Word Track: “Morning [Customer Name], just wanted to check if you had a chance to watch the video I sent over for the [Vehicle]. Any initial questions I can answer for you via text?”
- Day 3 (Touch 7): Phone Call #3 (afternoon).
- Day 4 (Touch 8): Email #2. Provide new value. Link to a vehicle review, similar inventory, or a blog post on “5 Things to Know Before Buying a [Model].”
- Day 6 (Touch 9): “Checking In” Voice Note via Text. A personal audio message can cut through the noise.
- Voice Note Script: “Hey [Customer Name], [Agent Name] here. I know you’re busy, just wanted to check in personally and see if your vehicle search is still active. Let me know if I can help with anything at all.”
- Day 10 (Touch 10): The “Break-Up” Email/Text. This polite, professional closing often triggers a response from procrastinators.
- Word Track: “Hi [Customer Name], I’ve tried to connect a few times regarding your interest in the [Vehicle]. I’ll assume your priorities have shifted for now and won’t continue to bother you. If you need me in the future, my contact info is below. Best of luck with your search.”
After Day 10, the lead moves into a long-term nurturing campaign (e.g., monthly email newsletter).
Cadence 2: The Unsold Showroom Traffic Lead
This customer has already visited your dealership. They are highly qualified, and the follow-up must be prompt, personal, and handled with care. The goal is to overcome the reason they didn’t buy.
The “Second Chance” Unsold Cadence (7 Touches)
- 2 Hours Post-Visit (Touch 1): Personal text from the BDC agent (on behalf of the salesperson).
- Word Track: “Hi [Customer Name], this is [BDC Agent] on behalf of [Salesperson Name]. He told me you were in today looking at the [Vehicle] and wanted me to thank you again for your time. He’s here to help if any questions come up after your visit.”
- Day 2 (Touch 2): Phone Call from BDC. The goal is discovery, not selling.
- Call Script: “Hi [Customer Name], this is [BDC Agent] calling from [Dealership Name]. I’m calling on behalf of [Salesperson]. We just wanted to follow up on your visit yesterday. On a scale of 1-10, how was your experience? What questions came to mind after you left?”
- Day 3 (Touch 3): Email with a summary and a new offer of value.
- Email Example: “Hi [Customer Name], It was a pleasure having you in. Based on your conversation with [Salesperson], I’ve attached the full vehicle details for the [Vehicle] you drove, plus two similar models that just arrived. When would be a good time to revisit?”
- Day 5 (Touch 4): Video message addressing a potential hesitation.
- Video Script: “Hey [Customer Name], [Salesperson] mentioned you had a question about the trade-in value. I’m standing with my manager right now, and we’d love to take another look at your vehicle to ensure we get you the absolute best value. Are you free to swing by for 15 minutes tomorrow?”
- Day 7, 14, 21 (Touches 5-7): Weekly check-in call or text. Keep it low-pressure, focusing on new inventory or incentives.
Cadence 3: The Service-to-Sales Opportunity
These are your customers. They already trust your dealership’s service department. The follow-up is about proactive opportunity identification, not aggressive selling.
The “Upgrade Opportunity” Cadence
- Trigger: Service advisor identifies a customer with an older vehicle or high repair cost. They get the customer’s permission for a BDC follow-up.
- Day 1 (Touch 1): BDC agent sends a text message.
- Word Track: “Hi [Customer Name], this is [BDC Agent] with [Dealership Name]. Your service advisor, [Advisor Name], asked me to reach out. While your [Customer’s Vehicle] is in for service, we’re offering complimentary equity reviews. We’ve seen record-high values for vehicles like yours. Would you be interested in a quick, no-obligation appraisal?”
- Day 1 (Touch 2): Phone Call to schedule the appraisal while they are at the dealership.
- If No Contact: Move to a 3-touch follow-up over the next week (Call, Email, Text) referencing the service visit and the equity opportunity. This alignment between fixed and variable ops is a hallmark of high-performing dealerships, a synergy Pinnacle Dealer Solutions helps to foster.
The Psychology of Timing: When to Reach Out
When you contact a lead can be as important as what you say. General best practices suggest that the best times to make contact are Wednesdays and Thursdays between 4:00 PM and 6:00 PM, followed closely by mid-mornings between 10:00 AM and 11:00 AM.
- Why Late Afternoon? People are winding down their workday, are less likely to be in a meeting, and may be planning their evening or weekend (which could include a dealership visit).
- Why Mid-Morning? The initial morning rush is over, and people are settled into their workday but not yet focused on lunch.
- Avoid Mondays: Everyone is catching up from the weekend. Your message is more likely to get lost.
- Avoid Lunchtime (12 PM – 2 PM): This is a protected personal time for most people.
Crucially, your CRM should track the time of the initial lead submission. If a lead comes in at 10:00 PM on a Saturday, your first manual follow-up call should not be at 9:00 AM on Monday. Try to mirror their activity. A text on Sunday afternoon might be far more effective. Effective CRM training for dealerships teaches BDC agents how to use this data to make smarter contact decisions.
Advanced Word Tracks and Objection Handling
Persistence is only effective if your messaging is right. Every touch must feel valuable, not repetitive. This is where mastering dealership BDC scripts is essential.
Word Tracks for Mid-Cadence Touches:
- The “New Information” Angle: “Hi [Customer Name], [Agent Name] from [Dealership Name]. Something new just came up regarding the [Vehicle] we discussed—a new incentive was just announced that I thought you’d want to know about.”
- The “Similar Vehicle” Angle: “Hi [Customer Name], I know you were interested in the silver [Model], which was sold. However, a nearly identical one in charcoal gray with lower miles just came in on trade. I’m sending a video of it to you now.”
- The “Quick Question” Angle (Text): “Hey [Customer Name], quick question for you—are you still in the market for a new SUV, or have you already found one?”
Handling Common Objections:
- “I’m just looking.”
- Response: “That’s perfect! Most of our customers are in the research phase when they first reach out. My job isn’t to sell you a car today, but simply to provide the information you need for your research. To that end, would a 15-minute visit to compare the [Model A] and [Model B] side-by-side be helpful?”
- “I don’t have time to come in.”
- Response: “I completely understand how busy life can get. That’s why we focus on ‘priority appointments.’ We’ll have the vehicle you’re interested in pulled up, cleaned, and ready to go. We can have you in and out for a test drive in under 20 minutes. Would Tuesday at 5:30 PM work?”
- “Your price is too high.”
- Response: “I appreciate you sharing that. Pricing is certainly important. To make sure we’re comparing apples to apples, could you tell me what other vehicles you’re comparing it to? Often, differences in trim, condition, or certification can affect the value. The best way to see the full value is to experience the vehicle in person. We can review the full breakdown together then.”
Effective objection handling isn’t about arguing; it’s about acknowledging, reframing, and redirecting back to the appointment. This is a core skill developed through the role-playing and live call evaluations provided in our Pinnacle Dealer Solutions BDC training programs.
The Manager’s Toolkit: KPIs, Scorecards, and Rollout Plan
To transform your automotive BDC performance, managers need a framework for tracking, coaching, and accountability.
Key Follow-Up KPIs and Benchmarks
| KPI | Description | Underperforming | Average | High-Performing |
| Contact Rate | % of leads where a two-way conversation occurs. | < 40% | 40-55% | 60%+ |
| Follow-Up Adherence | % of leads that receive the full, prescribed cadence. | < 70% | 70-85% | 90%+ |
| Lead-to-Appointment Rate | % of total leads that set an appointment. | < 15% | 15-22% | 25%+ |
| 60-Day Reactivation Rate | % of “closed-lost” leads reactivated into a sale. | < 3% | 4-7% | 8%+ |
The Manager’s Weekly Scorecard
Track each agent’s performance on these KPIs. This scorecard should be the basis for your weekly BDC coaching sessions.
- Total Leads Received:
- Total Outbound Attempts (Calls, Texts, Emails):
- Contact Rate:
- Appointments Set:
- Appointments Shown:
- Follow-Up Adherence Score (audited from CRM):
Quality Assurance: The Call & Cadence Audit
A BDC manager or team lead should spend time each day auditing agent activity in the CRM.
- Cadence Audit: Pull a sample of 10-15 leads per agent per week. Did they follow the prescribed cadence? Were the notes clear?
- Call Audit: Listen to recorded calls. Was the tone professional? Did they use the correct word tracks? Did they effectively handle objections?
- Feedback Loop: Use a simple scoring rubric and review it with the agent during your one-on-one coaching sessions. Focus on one or two areas for improvement at a time.
30/60/90 Day Rollout Plan
- First 30 Days: Foundation & Training
- Define and document your follow-up cadences for each lead type in your CRM.
- Conduct comprehensive automotive BDC training on the new processes, scripts, and the “why” behind them. Use extensive role-playing.
- Implement your chosen SMS and video platforms and provide technology training.
- Ensure all TCPA consent language is updated on lead forms.
- Next 60 Days: Execution & Coaching
- Go live with the new cadences.
- Managers focus heavily on daily activity monitoring and CRM audits.
- Implement weekly one-on-one BDC coaching sessions based on scorecard performance and call audits.
- Celebrate early wins and build momentum.
- Final 90 Days: Optimization & Accountability
- Analyze your 60-day KPI data. Which cadences are working best? Which agents need more support?
- Refine word tracks and timing based on real-world results.
- Introduce formal accountability systems. Performance against KPIs should be tied to agent compensation or recognition programs.
https://pinnaclesalesandmail.com/sales-consultant-training
https://pinnaclesalesandmail.com/sales-bdc-training
https://pinnaclesalesandmail.com/sales-management-training
The Outsourced BDC Option: Professional Persistence Without the Headaches
For many dealerships, building and maintaining a high-performing in-house BDC is a constant struggle with turnover, training, and accountability. This is where an outsourced solution can be a game-changer. Pinnacle Dealer Solutions offers a fully managed Outsourced Sales BDC that executes these proven follow-up strategies on your behalf.
Our professional team provides:
- Immediate, brand-compliant follow-up on every lead.
- Execution of relentless, data-driven follow-up cadences.
- Seamless integration with your CRM for full transparency.
- Guaranteed adherence to process without the internal management burden.
This allows your dealership to benefit from expert-level lead management and persistence from day one, turning missed opportunities into a predictable stream of showroom traffic.
Conclusion: Stop Leaving Money on the Table
Success in automotive retail is a game of inches, and mastering the science of follow-up gives you a critical edge. By moving away from inconsistent efforts and embracing a structured, multi-channel, and persistent process, you meet customers on their terms and engage them throughout their buying journey. This approach requires a clear plan, the right scripts, robust training, and a culture of accountability.
The data is clear: most of your potential is hidden in the fifth, sixth, and even tenth contact attempt. A well-trained and well-managed BDC that understands this science will consistently outperform competitors who give up too early.
Whether you are looking to elevate your current team with our customized lead management training or want to implement a turnkey solution with our outsourced services, Pinnacle Dealer Solutions is your partner in building a high-performance BDC. We provide the real-world coaching, accountability systems, and performance analytics needed to transform your follow-up process from a liability into your most powerful asset.
Ready to unlock the hidden revenue in your CRM? Contact Pinnacle Dealer Solutions today to schedule a performance analysis and discover how our BDC programs can drive unprecedented growth for your dealership.





