What Every Dealership Gets Wrong About Internet Leads

For nearly two decades, internet leads have been a fundamental part of automotive retail. Dealerships invest millions of dollars annually to generate a steady stream of these digital hand-raisers. Yet, despite their long-standing presence, a cloud of myth and misunderstanding still surrounds them. Many dealership leaders operate with an outdated mindset, viewing internet leads as low-quality, price-obsessed tire-kickers. This flawed perspective leads to flawed processes, frustrated teams, and a massive amount of wasted opportunity.

The truth is, internet leads are the lifeblood of the modern showroom. They represent customers who are actively in the market, have done their research, and have explicitly asked for contact. The problem isn’t the quality of the lead; it’s the quality of the dealership’s response. The dealerships that consistently dominate their markets are the ones that have debunked the old myths and embraced a modern, data-driven, and disciplined approach to internet lead management.

This guide will dismantle the most common and costly misconceptions every dealership has about internet leads. We will replace fiction with fact and provide a clear, actionable framework for transforming your internet lead process from a point of weakness into your most powerful competitive advantage.

The 5 Great Myths of Internet Lead Management

Let’s dissect the five myths that are most likely costing your dealership sales right now and replace them with the data-driven reality of a modern sales BDC process.

Myth #1: “Internet leads are low-quality.”

The Misconception: This is the most pervasive myth. Sales teams often complain that internet leads are “junk”—unresponsive, unqualified, and not serious buyers. This becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, as teams put minimal effort into leads they already believe are worthless.

The Reality: An internet lead is a person who has taken time out of their day to find your dealership online, select a vehicle, and fill out a form with their personal contact information. This is a high-intent action. The “quality” issue is almost always a reflection of a poor follow-up process. A lead that isn’t contacted for three hours becomes a low-quality lead because they have already been engaged by a faster competitor or have moved on. The lead quality didn’t change; your chance of converting it did.

The Fix:

  1. Shift Your Mindset: Treat every internet lead like a customer who just walked onto your showroom floor. It’s a real person with a real need.
  2. Measure the Right Thing: Instead of judging lead “quality,” measure your process quality. Track your lead response time, contact rate, and follow-up cadence adherence.
  3. Source Accountability: While most leads are good, some lead providers are better than others. Use your CRM to track your lead-to-sale conversion rate by source. Make data-driven decisions about your marketing budget, investing more in sources that deliver customers, not just clicks.

Myth #2: “They are only shopping for the lowest price.”

The Misconception: Many believe internet shoppers are purely transactional and will always buy from the dealership with the lowest advertised price. This leads BDC and sales teams to immediately jump into price negotiations over the phone or email, often resulting in a race to the bottom that erodes gross profit.

The Reality: While price is certainly a factor, it is rarely the only factor. Customers shop online for convenience, selection, and information. They are looking for a dealership that is responsive, professional, and makes the process easy. A great customer experience and a relationship built on trust will often win the sale, even if your price isn’t the absolute lowest in town. Value is more than just price; it’s the total experience.

The Fix:

  1. Train Value-Building, Not Discounting: Your BDC’s job is not to be a negotiator; it’s to be a value-creator. Instead of answering the price question with a number, train them to answer it with a process.
    Word Track: “That’s a great question, and I want to get you a 100% transparent and accurate price. Our online price is very competitive, but to give you a complete and final number, we need to account for any current incentives you qualify for and your trade-in value. The only way to get you a firm, guaranteed figure is with a quick 15-minute review here at the dealership. This way, you get a firm number with no surprises.”
  2. Sell the Appointment, Not the Car: The goal of the initial interaction is to sell the value of a visit to your dealership, where your highly-trained sales team can build value in person. Learn more about professionalizing your sales team at https://pinnaclesalesandmail.com/sales-consultant-training.

Myth #3: “If they don’t answer the first time, they’re not interested.”

The Misconception: Salespeople are busy. If they make one or two calls to a new lead and get no answer, they often mark the lead as “bad” and move on. This “one-and-done” approach is a catastrophic waste of marketing dollars.

The Reality: People are busy. They may be in a meeting, driving, or with their family when you call. A lack of an immediate answer is not a lack of interest. Data consistently shows that it takes, on average, 8-12 contact attempts to reach and engage an internet lead. Persistence is the key to converting them.

The Fix:

  1. Implement a Mandatory Multi-Channel Cadence: Your car dealership BDC must operate on a non-negotiable follow-up cadence. A proven model is 12-15 touches over 21 days.
    • The “Day-1 Blitz”: The first 24 hours are critical. This should include multiple phone calls, texts, and emails.
    • The Follow-Through: The cadence should continue with strategically spaced-out touches over the next three weeks.
  2. Use Varied Channels: Don’t just call. A customer who doesn’t answer the phone might respond instantly to a text message. A well-crafted email or a personalized video can break through the noise.
  3. Automate Task Management: Use your CRM to automatically schedule every follow-up task. This removes human error and ensures the process is followed every single time. This is a core competency taught in expert automotive BDC training. More information is available at https://pinnaclesalesandmail.com/sales-bdc-training.

Myth #4: “A quick email response is good enough.”

The Misconception: Some dealerships believe that as long as they send a fast, automated email response, they have met their speed-to-lead obligation.

The Reality: An automated email is a passive form of communication that places the burden on the customer to re-engage. It does not create a conversation. A phone call is, and always will be, the most effective first response because it allows for a real, two-way dialogue where rapport can be built and an appointment can be set. The goal is to have a conversation, not just check a box.

The Fix:

  1. Phone Call First, Always: The first action for every new lead must be a phone call. If it goes to voicemail, then you immediately follow up with a text and email.
  2. The “Trifecta” Approach: The best initial response is a combination of all three within the first five minutes. Leave a compelling voicemail, send a personal text referencing the voicemail, and send a professional email with a clear call to action.
  3. Personalize, Don’t Automate (The First Touch): While automation is great for reminders, the very first email and text should be personalized by the BDC agent. It should reference the specific vehicle and use the agent’s name. It signals that a real person is handling their inquiry.

Myth #5: “Anyone can handle internet leads.”

The Misconception: Many dealerships treat lead management as an entry-level task, assigning it to green salespeople or receptionists with no specialized training. Or, they add it to the already-full plate of their floor sales team.

The Reality: Handling internet leads effectively is a specialized skill. It requires a unique combination of process discipline, resilience, excellent written and verbal communication skills, and technological proficiency. A great floor salesperson who excels at face-to-face interaction may be terrible at the structured, persistent follow-up required for internet leads. Assigning this critical task to untrained or distracted personnel is the primary reason BDCs fail.

The Fix:

  1. Create a Specialized, Dedicated BDC: The agents responsible for internet leads must be 100% dedicated to that task. They should not be juggling floor traffic or other duties. This focus is what allows for the necessary speed and persistence.
  2. Invest in Specialized Training: Your BDC agents need their own unique training path that focuses on phone skills, script mastery, objection handling, and CRM discipline.
  3. Hire for the Right Profile: When hiring for your BDC, look for candidates with high emotional intelligence, coachability, and a process-oriented mindset. These traits are more important than previous car sales experience.
  4. Provide Expert Management: The BDC needs a dedicated manager who is an expert in process, coaching, and data analysis. This role is too important to be a part-time responsibility for a sales manager. For managers needing to acquire these skills, professional sales management training is a wise investment: https://pinnaclesalesandmail.com/sales-management-training.

Building the Modern Internet Lead Management Machine

Debunking the myths is the first step. The next is to build a system based on reality. A modern internet lead process is built on:

  • Staffing: A dedicated, specialized, and well-trained BDC team.
  • Process: A disciplined system built on the pillars of speed (<5 minutes) and persistence (12-15 touches).
  • Technology: A CRM that is used to enforce the process through task automation and provides clear reporting through real-time dashboards.
  • Accountability: Leadership that inspects what they expect, holding the team accountable to core KPIs like response time, contact rate, and task completion.

Conclusion: The Opportunity is Real

The narrative that internet leads are “bad” is a convenient excuse for a bad process. The top-performing dealerships in the country have proven that when handled with speed, skill, and persistence, internet leads are the most predictable and scalable source of showroom traffic available. By challenging the old myths and embracing a modern, data-driven approach, you can stop wasting your marketing dollars and start converting a significantly higher percentage of your digital opportunities into sales.

The transformation begins with a commitment from leadership to reject the old excuses and invest in the people, processes, and training required to win.

Pinnacle Dealer Solutions is a leader in helping dealerships master their internet lead process. Our training programs and outsourced BDC solutions are built on the data-driven realities of modern automotive retail, not the outdated myths of the past. We provide the systems, scripts, and coaching to transform your lead management from a source of frustration into a center of excellence.

Ready to stop making excuses and start making more sales from your internet leads? Contact Pinnacle Dealer Solutions today for a complimentary lead process audit. We’ll show you exactly where your opportunities are being lost and how to fix it. Visit https://pinnaclesalesandmail.com/sales-bdc-training to get started.

 

related Blogs